December 18, 2018 3 min read

 Spining a Fly Rod - To Spine or not to Spine

  • Fly rod blanks tend to naturally want to bed more in one direction than the other. This is caused by an effect called the “Spine” and often there is more than one on a blank. The spine is a result of the manufacturing process and is the location of the join or overlap of a graphite or glass flag as it is rolled around the mandrel.
  • Basically it is a slightly thicker section in the tube wall. This thick section is slightly stiffer than the rest of the tube and presents a greater resistance to bending. (Blanks that use helical wound construction tend not to exhibit a pronounced spine)
  • You can find the spine in your blank by holding the blank at a 45 degree angle with one hand near the tip and then by pressing down and rotating at the same time with your other hand. The resistance you feel are the high points or spine. 
  • You’ll likely feel the blank Jump or pop over and want to sit a certain way. You may feel a couple of potential spines, but somewhere in there you’ll feel the most pronounced pop ,or reaction to your bending. When you get to this spot - you’ve spined your blank.
  • The inside of the curve (where the blank has come to rest under your fingers) is the softer side of the blank. The outside of the curve is actually where the spine is - the stiffer side.

Spining a fly rod finding he spine on a fly rod

 

Now that you found the spine you have at least 4 choices what to do with it.

  1. Place the guides on the inside of the curve - the weaker side. The natural curve. The thinking here is that placing your guides on the inside curve may result in the rod being (moderately) stiffer on the forward cast and the rod will sit more naturally when fighting fish. (it's actually going to bend in any direction it's pulled)
  2. Place the guides on the outside of the curve - the (marginally) stiffer side. By placing the guides on the outside of the curve you may get (marginally) better lifting power, as you will be pulling against the spine or natural curve of the blank.
  3. Place the guides out at 90 degrees to the spine. I’e off to the side at right angles to the spine. Don Green, the great rod designer for Fenwick and Sage advocated this method. His reasoning was that the rod should track straight on both backcast as well as forward cast in order to be most accurate.
    Putting the spine on the top or bottom of the rod means that the rod will tend to kick slightly out of line on either the back or forward cast. By placing the spine out at 90 degrees the spine will apply the same effect whether on the back or forward cast.
  4. Ignore the spine altogether and align the rod sections to give the straightest most aesthetically pleasing result. (our preference) This is what most commercial rod manufacturers do.


The Truth?

The subject of spining rods has caused & continues to cause huge debate. The truth is that under the tension of the cast the rod will always bend according to the tension of the fly line against the guides and tiptop, the effect of the spine on a fully loaded rod is negligible. - So truly, it matters little (all respect to the great Don Green) 

Do what you feel is best for your build, it's your fly rod - follow your bliss.



Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The Drift - Fly Fishing, Fly Casting and Fly Rod Building

Fly Fishing Fly Rod ratings and Fly Lines
Fly Fishing: Fly Rod Ratings, Fly Line Weights and the Arms Race

February 18, 2020 7 min read

At best the term “5 weight’ is used to describe the weight of fly line a given fly rod designer reckons you should be casting on their rod. But with line measurement effectively out the window, things are really starting to go pear shaped here....
Read More
Fly Fishing fly lines floating vs sinking fly lines
Fly Fishing - Floating Fly Lines vs Sinking Fly Lines - Which Weighs More?

February 10, 2020 2 min read

Which weighs more, a floating fly line or a sinking line? It may surprise you to know that they both weigh the same - at 30 feet anyway. Or at least they should.
For example, under the AFFTA system for rating fly lines a 5 weight fly line is a 5wt regardless of whether it is a floater, a sinking fly line or an intermediate.

Read More
Best fly rods Custom Fly Rods By Epic
Build the Best Fly Rod

February 03, 2020 3 min read

Last year at one of our regular "How do we make these better" chats (we dont have any meetings around here) - Trev suggested we take a closer look at the new Fuji Torzite stripping guides - I have to admit to being a little sceptical, to date we'd been using a very good titanium stripping guide produced by Alps. They're top notch.....
Read More

Join Us